My point was that it’s never been entirely one way or another. You can cite examples of aggressively progressive comic like X-men or the Superman-KKK comics, but the super hero format itself leans libertarian and if the writer isn’t careful, they end up supporting that or worse, a libertarian writer promotes those ideas while hiding behind the canon of super heroes. I’ve heard some batshit takes from otherwise progressive comicbook readers.
OK, but specifically back when comics were first coming out and becoming popular. I don’t think there were pro-fascist comics in the 60s in 70s, for one because a big chunk of their market were hippies. But maybe I’m wrong.
but the super hero format itself leans libertarian
You’re probably not wrong, which is why the ones that lean into it (like The Boys or Invincible) always seem more realistic.
I remember when comics were overtly anti-fascist.
Many of the characters’ entire personas are inextricably linked to anti-fascism.
Really depends on the writer. I know The Dark Knight Returns is beloved, but there’s the themes in it that I’m not so sure about.
I guess I’m thinking more about classic comics from the 60s and 70s. Your X-Men and what have you.
My point was that it’s never been entirely one way or another. You can cite examples of aggressively progressive comic like X-men or the Superman-KKK comics, but the super hero format itself leans libertarian and if the writer isn’t careful, they end up supporting that or worse, a libertarian writer promotes those ideas while hiding behind the canon of super heroes. I’ve heard some batshit takes from otherwise progressive comicbook readers.
OK, but specifically back when comics were first coming out and becoming popular. I don’t think there were pro-fascist comics in the 60s in 70s, for one because a big chunk of their market were hippies. But maybe I’m wrong.
You’re probably not wrong, which is why the ones that lean into it (like The Boys or Invincible) always seem more realistic.