Not nitpick but first of all great answer. no sarcasm. But if I go into a known nazi/skinhead bar and start fighting them because they are Nazi’s is that a hate crime? Even though their whole thing is hate, we fought a war against them, and are generally despised?
Generally speaking, hate crimes are only applicable to crimes motivated by a hatred for an immutable trait. Social or political ideology isn’t immutable, so it wouldn’t be protected.
That’s a good point; I had overlooked that as a category. That said, it is sort of the odd one out in terms of “immutable traits” (notwithstanding Jews specifically, at least when referring to ethnicity rather than religion).
Not nitpick but first of all great answer. no sarcasm. But if I go into a known nazi/skinhead bar and start fighting them because they are Nazi’s is that a hate crime? Even though their whole thing is hate, we fought a war against them, and are generally despised?
Nazis are not a protected class yet.
💀
No, it’s not a protected characteristic because being a nazi isn’t innate.
Generally speaking, hate crimes are only applicable to crimes motivated by a hatred for an immutable trait. Social or political ideology isn’t immutable, so it wouldn’t be protected.
I thought being religiously motivated also would qualify as a hate crime? Or is the implication that one’s religion is also immutable?
That’s a good point; I had overlooked that as a category. That said, it is sort of the odd one out in terms of “immutable traits” (notwithstanding Jews specifically, at least when referring to ethnicity rather than religion).