The vast majority of the increase in these people’s wealth over time is newly-created; it’s value that literally didn’t exist before, not an amount of cash money taken away from anyone else.
A wealth tax will go after that, and that will absolutely make sense. They can sell the shares they have in the companies, and that will make them think twice before cheating the system to grossely exagerate the value of their companies.
And if we talk about start-ups or other special cases where the CEOs can’t sell shares and/or we don’t really know their worth, we can have them give shares as payment. The gov will sit on them until they have actual value and sell them, or relesase them back if said value was lower than estimated at the time.
A wealth tax will go after that, and that will absolutely make sense.
It absolutely doesn’t make sense to charge a tax of real/actual money on a value that’s theoretical.
They can sell the shares they have in the companies, and that will make them think twice before cheating the system to grossely exagerate the value of their companies.
It’s irrational to assume “cheating the system to grossely [sic] exagerate [sic] the value of their companies” of every entity valued at more than an arbitrary $X.
It absolutely doesn’t make sense to charge a tax of real/actual money on a value that’s theoretical.
That “theoretical value” is used as collateral to borrow money for billionaires expenses.
Companies can even buy one another through shares exchange. So tell me:
Why is it theoretical only for taxes purpose, but very real when you talk to a bank?.
It’s irrational to assume “cheating the system to grossely [sic] exagerate [sic] the value of their companies” of every entity valued at more than an arbitrary $X.
I didn’t write it was all of them. I’m talking about the AI bubble and IPO scams.
“The stuff you own is now too valuable, so we get to steal it from you.”
Is that your opinion on properties taxes? Because that’s something you own, and you pay a tax based on its value. That value is also theoretical, by the way: as long as you don’t sell the house, who knows how much it’s worth?
And… is that not the most expensive thing you own??
Or is it stealing only when we talk about billionaires wealth?
And at this scale, it’s not “stuff you own”. You may have an issue assessing what a billion is. Do you know the difference between a million and a billion? It’s roughly a billion…
That 20M$ mansion gaining 10% is absolutely peanuts.
A wealth tax will go after that, and that will absolutely make sense. They can sell the shares they have in the companies, and that will make them think twice before cheating the system to grossely exagerate the value of their companies.
And if we talk about start-ups or other special cases where the CEOs can’t sell shares and/or we don’t really know their worth, we can have them give shares as payment. The gov will sit on them until they have actual value and sell them, or relesase them back if said value was lower than estimated at the time.
It absolutely doesn’t make sense to charge a tax of real/actual money on a value that’s theoretical.
It’s irrational to assume “cheating the system to grossely [sic] exagerate [sic] the value of their companies” of every entity valued at more than an arbitrary $X.
For example, Costco is a company worth hundreds of billions of dollars, and yet it’s famous for how generous it is both to its customers and to its workforce. Its founder left the company a billionaire himself.
“The stuff you own is now too valuable, so we get to steal it from you.”
No.
That “theoretical value” is used as collateral to borrow money for billionaires expenses. Companies can even buy one another through shares exchange. So tell me:
Why is it theoretical only for taxes purpose, but very real when you talk to a bank?.
I didn’t write it was all of them. I’m talking about the AI bubble and IPO scams.
Is that your opinion on properties taxes? Because that’s something you own, and you pay a tax based on its value. That value is also theoretical, by the way: as long as you don’t sell the house, who knows how much it’s worth?
And… is that not the most expensive thing you own??
Or is it stealing only when we talk about billionaires wealth?
And at this scale, it’s not “stuff you own”. You may have an issue assessing what a billion is. Do you know the difference between a million and a billion? It’s roughly a billion…
That 20M$ mansion gaining 10% is absolutely peanuts.