• 0 Posts
  • 10 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 11th, 2024

help-circle
  • As I said in my comment, the technology they use for these cancer screening tools isnt an LLM, its a completely different technology. Specifically trained on scans to find cancer.

    I don’t think it would have the same feedback loop of bad training data because you can easily verify the results. AI tool sees cancer in a scan? Verify with the next test. Pretty easy binary test that won’t be affected by poor doctor performance in reading the same scans.

    I’m not a medical professional so I could be off on that chain of events but This technology isn’t an LLM. It suffers from the marketing hype right now where everyone is calling everything AI but its a different technology and has different pros and cons, and different potential failures.

    I do agree that the whole AI doesnt have bias is BS. It has the same bias that its training data has.


  • I don’t think its fair to say that “ai has shown to make doctors worse at their jobs” without further details. In the source you provided it says that after a few months of using the AI to detect polyps, the doctors performed worse when they couldn’t use the AI than they did originally.

    It’s not something we should handwave away and say its not a potential problem, but it is a different problem. I bet people that use calculators perform worse when you remove calculators, does that mean we should never use calculators? Or any tools for that matter?

    If I have a better chance of getting an accurate cancer screening because a doctor is using a machine learning tool I’m going to take that option. Note that these screening tools are completely different from the technology most people refer to when they say AI





  • No idea :/ I’m not in the market for a new phone so I haven’t been paying attention to what’s out there.

    I’m hoping fairphone can/does get better at updating older devices before I need to get another phone so I can stick with them.

    I have gotten security updates and occasional bugfixes but it does feel like they’ve done the bare minimum to fulfill their promise of supporting phones for a long time.


  • Compared to the flagships of the time it was pretty noticeable. When it was new it seemed like the camera was maybe 3 or 4 generations behind. You could probably find some comparisons for the new generation of fairphone and see what its like. It works for my use case because I bring out an actual camera for photography.

    My current main gripe is android auto and bluetooth (separately) disconnect randomly when I’m in a vehicle. Usually comes back on its own but I have to refresh the screen. To give FP the benefit of the doubt it could be a problem with my aftermarket stereo, but its a decent brand.


  • Currently writing this on a fairphone 4.

    I love the hardware aside from the camera, but that was a sacrifice I knew I was making going in to it.

    My big complaint is the software. It has never really been fully stable. During the best patches things work most of the time, but there have also been some pretty bad bugs. Again, I knew the updates would be slower and bugs might take longer to fix due to a smaller Dev team but I didn’t expect it to be this bad. It does feel like they just gave up on the 4 to work on the 5 and 6. At this point I’m 2 major android versions behind.

    I love that when I broke the screen I was able to replace it in 5 minutes, and I want to be a big supporter of fairphone. I even went to the trouble of importing the phone and replacement parts to Canada.

    I don’t know if this is also an issue with custom ROMS but if this doesn’t change I don’t know that I’ll get another when the time comes.