I am sure this article has been shared before, however I wanted to have a look at this topic.
The articles short summary is this:
All 25 car brands we researched earned our *Privacy Not Included warning label – making cars the worst category of products that we have ever reviewed
I am currently driving a 2014 Ford Fiesta which just has a radio with a CD player and Bluetooth. I do not need more than that in a car.
The reason I am looking at all is that that the Fiesta does not belong to me and the friend owning it will be moving out in a bit, so I kinda need another one.
There seems to be one brand that is not as bad as the other ones (but still bad): Renault; mozilla’s review…
Maybe I will have a look at their cars.
What do you guys think? Stick to older used cars and not use an EV or look at which of the manufacturers have the least bad privacy policy?
Sorry to burst your bubble, but the sensors store data locally and then get uploaded to the Internet when you take it to a mechanic, who plugs your car into an internet-connected computer.
You have to neuter the sensors, not just the cell antenna
Source?
https://odysee.com/Privacy4Cars:d9ae4addf27ac9b0d6e3aee1786ed573a0af3d83
A lot of cars do have EDRs (Event Data Recorders), but they only store certain events related to crashes so they can go back and establishes what was going on before an accident.
AFAIK, regular telemetry going out the cell is much more extensive, continuous, and realtime.
https://crashdatagroup.com/pages/edr-explained
Its not the sensors that store the data, the ecu/pcm/bcm do that. Yes, there is essentially a black box function in most modern-ish cars that logs the last X minutes of driving. It likely also has an “event recorder” for when certain conditions are triggered.
I know for a fact that most have reflash counters or log when the ecu was written to last. That is more to do with tuning or warranty stuff but still.
Of course, but the computer won’t store any sensitive data if you neuter the sensors.
Yeah that isn’t an option unless you want the dash to light up like a Christmas tree, your abs not to work, the stability/traction control to freak out and disable your accellerator, or cause an airbag fault, or cause the seatbelt pretensioners to fault.
You’re saying the airbag will deeply if I feed it a black feed from the cameras and silence from the microphones? Huh.
No, I am saying if you disable or tweak the sensors that feed the onboard telemetry system on a modern car which include sensors for the accelerator pedal position, vehicle speed, individual wheel speed sensors (for abs, traction control, and stability control), the car will probably freak out and enter limp mode.
If you screw with the stability or traction sensors, they can cause the airbags to not trigger properly or predictably. Remember, there are basic impact sensors for airbags but there are also angle sensors and accelerometers for rollover detection now. If you disable any of that, the car will not work properly.
Yeah, and I’m saying that those aren’t the sensors that we need to neuter. Namely the surveillance sensors are cameras, microphones, and seat sensors.
Basically all the things that they use to sell your sexual habits to the highest bidder.
They still get loads of telemetry from those other sensors.
Accelerometers don’t only get used for rollover. They also measure how you use the car.