It’s not that confusing.
It’s arguing a fallacy implies a false conclusion.
A more common fallacy around here is to claim that merely identifying a fallacy is an instance of argument from fallacy when rejecting invalid arguments is logical.
I don’t know what you’re trying to say.
When someone identifies a fallacy & ends it right there, what do you expect them to do?
Pretend your argument doesn’t suck?
The very least you can do is provide a valid argument.
It’s not that confusing. It’s arguing a fallacy implies a false conclusion.
A more common fallacy around here is to claim that merely identifying a fallacy is an instance of argument from fallacy when rejecting invalid arguments is logical.
When the comment begins and ends with “That’s an <X> fallacy” and ending any further introspection?
“My mom said the sky is blue”
“That’s an Argument from Authority! Fallacy!”
When “fallacy!” becomes a thought-terminating response, it’s just debatebro shit.
I don’t know what you’re trying to say. When someone identifies a fallacy & ends it right there, what do you expect them to do? Pretend your argument doesn’t suck?
The very least you can do is provide a valid argument.