Love the first two Kelvin movies, third one killed it for me. Watched it several times, no memories of it except the amusing opening.

That’s the main way I rate movies in my head. Did I wake the next morning thinking about it? Did I want to watch it again immediately and catch what I was too excited to catch on the first viewing?

Those first two were great. They actors and their direction captured the original characters without making hollow caricatures of them. (Bones was slightly over the top.) Great, but time to move on.